📍 New York Italian $$$

What to Order at
Lilia

At Lilia ($$$), our food critics consistently recommend: Mafaldini, Agnolotti dal Plin, Grilled Prawns. Mafaldini scores 97.5/100 on our credibility scale — based on expert assessments from chefs, sommeliers, and food critics.

Ask FoodTree on WhatsApp

Insider Picks

Top Dishes — Ranked by Expert Credibility

#1

Mafaldini

97.5/100

Pink peppercorn, prosecco, and Parmigiano cream sauce on ruffled pasta

"The pink peppercorn cream catches in every ruffled edge of the mafaldini. The prosecco adds lift. Parmigiano adds depth. This is the rare dish that is both technically impressive and immediately pleas…"

#2

Agnolotti dal Plin

96.0/100

Tiny pinched pasta filled with braised meats in sage butter

"Lilia's agnolotti dal plin are the finest pasta in the city. Missy Robbins makes them by hand — the pinched edges, the filling of braised meats, the sage brown butter sauce. They are smaller than most…"

Get picks like these in your inbox

Weekly insider dish picks from New York — curated by chefs and food critics. Free.

#3

Grilled Prawns

92.0/100

Wood-grilled Sicilian red prawns with herbs and lemon

"The wood-grilled Sicilian red prawns at Lilia arrive with the head on, charred at the edges, and a smell of sea and char. The herbs and lemon are a simple finish that respects the quality of the produ…"

Still deciding?
Just ask.

Text us the restaurant name and we'll reply with the exact dishes to order — backed by chefs and food critics.

Text Us on WhatsApp

+1 (415) 523-8886 · Free to text