📍 New York Italian-American $$$

What to Order at
Don Angie

At Don Angie ($$$), our food critics consistently recommend: Pinwheel Lasagna, Chicken Scarpariello, Meatballs. Pinwheel Lasagna scores 97.0/100 on our credibility scale — based on expert assessments from chefs, sommeliers, and food critics.

Ask FoodTree on WhatsApp

Insider Picks

Top Dishes — Ranked by Expert Credibility

#1

Pinwheel Lasagna

97.0/100

Spiral-cut lasagna with pink vodka sauce, burrata, and basil

"The pinwheel lasagna defies how lasagna is supposed to work. Each spiral is individually crispy at the edges and creamy at the center. The pink vodka sauce has enough acidity to cut through the burrat…"

#2

Chicken Scarpariello

95.0/100

Braised chicken thighs with sausage, peppers, and vinegar

"The chicken scarpariello at Don Angie is an Italian-American classic done without a single wrong note. Chicken thighs braised with Italian sausage, pickled cherry peppers, and enough vinegar to keep t…"

Get picks like these in your inbox

Weekly insider dish picks from New York — curated by chefs and food critics. Free.

#3

Meatballs

93.0/100

Grandmother-style beef and pork meatballs in red sauce

"Grandmother-style meatballs — which means they are enormous and the sauce is the thing. The meat is half beef, half pork, and they use the breadcrumbs from the bread service to bind them. The tomato s…"

Still deciding?
Just ask.

Text us the restaurant name and we'll reply with the exact dishes to order — backed by chefs and food critics.

Text Us on WhatsApp

+1 (415) 523-8886 · Free to text