📍 New York New York Pizza $$

What to Order at
Di Fara Pizza

At Di Fara Pizza ($$), our food critics consistently recommend: Regular Slice, Square Slice. Regular Slice scores 99.0/100 on our credibility scale — based on expert assessments from chefs, sommeliers, and food critics.

Ask FoodTree on WhatsApp

Insider Picks

Top Dishes — Ranked by Expert Credibility

#1

Regular Slice

99.0/100

Dom DeMarco's thin-crust round pizza with San Marzano tomato and three cheeses

"The cornicione bubbles are charred, not just golden. Inside, the crumb is open and chewy. The cheese distribution is deliberately irregular — that is the point."

#2

Square Slice

92.3/100

Thicker Sicilian-style square pie with charred edges and pools of mozzarella

"The square slice has a thicker crust with more structural integrity. Still that same sauce, same cheese, but with pools of oil at the edges that make every bite sing."

Get picks like these in your inbox

Weekly insider dish picks from New York — curated by chefs and food critics. Free.

Still deciding?
Just ask.

Text us the restaurant name and we'll reply with the exact dishes to order — backed by chefs and food critics.

Text Us on WhatsApp

+1 (415) 523-8886 · Free to text