Expert Score

Square Slice

📍 New York New York Pizza $$

at Di Fara Pizza

"The square slice has a thicker crust with more structural integrity. Still that same sauce, same cheese, but with pools of oil at the edges that make every bite sing."

— Expert, 97/100 credibility
Ask FoodTree on WhatsApp

Expert Reviews

What Critics Are Saying

Expert 97/100

"The square slice has a thicker crust with more structural integrity. Still that same sauce, same cheese, but with pools of oil at the edges that make every bite sing."

Expert 94/100

"Square pie energy is different from round pie energy. This has the structural confidence of something that was baked with certainty. The char on the bottom is non-negotiable."

Expert 86/100

"Square Slice at Di Fara Pizza — a Sicilian-style thick crust square, crisp on the bottom, fluffy within. The same sauce and cheese as the regular slice, scaled up into something that takes 20 minutes to eat alone."