Expert Score

Pepperoni Slice

📍 New York New York Pizza $

at Scarr's Pizza

"Regular Slice at Scarr's Pizza — the dough is cold-fermented for 48 hours before being hand-stretched and baked in a deck oven. The crust has a faint sourness from the long ferment that separates it from standard New York slices."

— Expert, 99/100 credibility
Ask FoodTree on WhatsApp

Expert Reviews

What Critics Are Saying

Expert 99/100

"Regular Slice at Scarr's Pizza — the dough is cold-fermented for 48 hours before being hand-stretched and baked in a deck oven. The crust has a faint sourness from the long ferment that separates it from standard New York slices."

Expert 97/100

"The pepperoni cups. That is the review. Cupped pepperoni is a structural choice, not a default, and Scarr's does it correctly — the edges char while the center renders. These are the details that separate pizza."

Expert 94/100

"The cheese blend is two parts mozzarella, one part something that makes it more interesting. The pepperoni has visible spice specks — actual chili, not food coloring. The whole thing is better than it has any right to be."