Expert Score

Corned Beef Sandwich

📍 New York Jewish Deli $$

at Katz's Delicatessen

"Corned Beef Sandwich at Katz's — the beef is cured in a brine of salt, sugar, and spices for two weeks, then slow-cooked until it can be sliced thin enough to see through. Served on rye with Russian dressing and a pickle. The alternative to pastrami, equally compelling."

— Expert, 99/100 credibility
Ask FoodTree on WhatsApp

Expert Reviews

What Critics Are Saying

Expert 99/100

"Corned Beef Sandwich at Katz's — the beef is cured in a brine of salt, sugar, and spices for two weeks, then slow-cooked until it can be sliced thin enough to see through. Served on rye with Russian dressing and a pickle. The alternative to pastrami, equally compelling."

Expert 94/100

"The corned beef at Katz's is the sleeper on the menu. Brinier and more mineral than the pastrami, with a different texture — more uniform, less smoky. Both are necessary. Order a half-sour pickle on the side. This is what New York tastes like."