📍 New York Italian-American Pizza $$$

What to Order at
Lucali

At Lucali ($$$), our food critics consistently recommend: Calzone, Classic Margherita Pizza. Calzone scores 99.0/100 on our credibility scale — based on expert assessments from chefs, sommeliers, and food critics.

Ask FoodTree on WhatsApp

More restaurants like this — get weekly picks

Insider Picks

Top Dishes — Ranked by Expert Credibility

#1

Calzone

99.0/100

Wood-fired calzone stuffed with ricotta and your choice of toppings

"Regular Slice at Di Fara Pizza — the classic New York slice, made by Dom DeMarco who has been hand-pressing dough and pulling pies since the 1960s. The sauce is seasoned with oregano and chilli flakes…"

#2

Classic Margherita Pizza

96.5/100

Hand-stretched dough, San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil — perfection

"Mark Iacono stretches the dough by hand into a near-perfect disk. The San Marzano tomatoes are barely cooked. The mozzarella pools and chars at the edges. Each pizza is different because each pizza is…"

Discover more spots like
Lucali

Weekly insider picks — the best dishes from our New York database, curated by chefs and food critics. No noise.

Still deciding?
Just ask.

Text us the restaurant name and we'll reply with the exact dishes to order — backed by chefs and food critics.

Text Us on WhatsApp

+1 (415) 523-8886 · Free to text