Expert Score

French Onion Soup

📍 New York French Brasserie $$$

at Balthazar

"French onion soup at Balthazar is a commitment — the onions are cooked until they are caramelized, dark, collapsed. The broth is beef-based, the Gruyere is applied thick, the crouton is inserted at the correct angle so it gets saturated without disintegrating."

— Expert, 93/100 credibility
Ask FoodTree on WhatsApp

Expert Reviews

What Critics Are Saying

Expert 93/100

"French onion soup at Balthazar is a commitment — the onions are cooked until they are caramelized, dark, collapsed. The broth is beef-based, the Gruyere is applied thick, the crouton is inserted at the correct angle so it gets saturated without disintegrating."

Expert 90/100

"The gratinee is the point. The cheese needs to bubble and brown and pull away from the edges of the crock. This requires a salamander, not an oven — the broiler must be positioned to hit the top of the cheese without melting the interior of the soup."